Planning Commission — Thursday, 5 November 2026
From the KCRT video of the meeting (about 2 hours 22 minutes; times below are video times), checked against the Planning Commission agenda, Nov 5. Compiled from KCRT video; votes are unconfirmed unless minutes are posted. Minutes of November 5 are not yet posted. Where a mover, second, or figure could not be heard clearly, this digest says so. The video was transcribed by machine; names are checked against the posted agenda where possible.
Attendance (about 0:10)
- Roll call answered by Chair Bruce Brubaker, Vice-Chair Diana Benitez and Commissioner Shahzaib Shahid. Secretary Gay Timmons was running late and was recorded present at about 0:16. Commissioner Jonathan Harrison was trying to join by video and was recorded absent at the vote on the public hearing. Two of the seven seats are vacant on the agenda.
- Staff: Planning Manager Avery Stark; Senior Planner Matthew Neuebaumer presented; Community Development Director Lina Velasco and Senior Assistant City Attorney James Atencio attended. Two environmental consultants (Acorn Environmental and ESA) attended; the Acorn consultant presented the environmental review. The applicant’s representative was Rachael Justice of Chevron.
Minutes, agenda review and consent
- Minutes of the previous meeting: the Chair asked for a motion; a commissioner said they had missed that meeting, and staff said three members who attended were needed to vote. The Commission set the item aside until the absent members arrived. The video does not show the Commission returning to it.
- No changes to the agenda. No consent calendar items.
Public forum (about 0:13)
- One speaker congratulated the Chair on his reappointment and recalled a January hearing at which a neighborhood council opposed a gas station’s request to sell alcohol, citing its distance from schools, store theft, hours of operation and traffic on Hilltop Mall Road. The speaker asked that neighborhood councils be given a chance to comment on projects before they reach the Design Review Board or the Commission. No one else spoke in the room or online.
G.1 — PLN24-098, Chevron Wet Gas Scrubber (public hearing, about 0:18–1:21)
- Request. Adopt an addendum to the 2018 EIR for the Air District’s Expedited BARCT Implementation Schedule project (State Clearinghouse No. 2018082003) and its mitigation monitoring program, and approve a conditional use permit and design review permit for a wet gas scrubber and support equipment at the Chevron Richmond Refinery. Staff recommended adopting Resolution 26-17, with 26 conditions.
- What staff said the project is. A wet gas scrubber on the refinery’s fluidized catalytic cracker, proposed to meet Air District Rule 6-5 limits on particulate matter (including condensable particulates), sulfur dioxide and ammonia. Staff said it would cut total PM10 emissions by about 44 percent, and that there would be no change in the crude oil processed, the type of crude or products, or the number of employees. The scrubber would stand about 199 feet; the zoning district’s 55-foot limit does not apply to refining process equipment, and staff said existing equipment on the parcel ranges from about 125 to 204 feet. Project site about 1.5 acres, with about 20.2 acres of possible construction laydown areas; construction about two years; 93 light fixtures, all shielded; two portable diesel fire-water pumps for emergency quench. The Design Review Board recommended conditional approval on June 10, 2026.
- Other approvals. A City building permit (with a condition that proof of the Air District’s authority-to-construct permit come first), an Air District permit to operate and Title V amendment, and Regional Water Quality Control Board approvals for the added purge stream under the refinery’s discharge permit.
- Environmental review (consultant). The City’s checklist covered all 20 CEQA topics and found no new or more severe impacts than in 2018, so an addendum was used. Construction air-quality mitigation measures A1 through A6 from 2018 carry over. A health risk analysis, run in several scenarios, was described as “orders of magnitude” below the Air District’s thresholds. Water supply remains significant and unavoidable, as in the 2018 EIR, which the City attorney’s office confirmed was the only such impact. Two 2018 measures were modified to allow recycled water at a separate cooling-water tower at the refinery; the consultant said the City cannot guarantee the Air District or East Bay MUD approvals that would require. The City released the addendum for voluntary review beginning May 27 (extended on request); seven comment letters were answered in a memo in the packet; tribal consultation was held.
- Changes at the meeting. Staff revised condition 14 (inadvertent discovery of tribal cultural resources) after tribal comments, so that the Community Development Director may reduce the protective buffer only after consulting the tribes; staff said the tribes had seen and agreed with the language. Staff also corrected a typographical error in use permit finding C (“40 percent” to “44 percent”).
- Applicant. The Chevron representative said Chevron supports the City’s analysis, the conditions and the mitigation measures.
- Commission questions before the hearing. On wastewater, the applicant said purge water goes to a treatment unit, solids are bagged in bins and shipped off site, and the water goes to the refinery’s existing wastewater plant and then to San Pablo Bay under its discharge permit; the applicant did not have removal percentages on hand. Asked whether the October 22 odor release was connected, staff and the applicant said the scrubber has not been built and is not connected to it. Staff said the recycled-water option is not a requirement of the project.
- Public hearing (about 0:58–1:06). Three speakers. A representative of the Contra Costa Building and Construction Trades Council and a colleague spoke in support, citing construction work for union members and apprentices. A speaker on Zoom who serves on the AB 617 Community Steering Committee supported the project, said the community had sought a scrubber for 15 to 20 years, urged staff to ask the Air District to fast-track permits, and asked whether the City had estimated added property tax revenue, recalling a project cost of about $450 million (his recollection; no answer is heard on the video). A Richmond resident on Zoom welcomed the shielded lighting and asked whether lighting color temperature could be under 3,000 Kelvin and whether the site would be tested for contamination before construction.
- Commission discussion (about 1:06–1:18). Questions covered the water finding, whether the Air District supports the project (staff said the City coordinated with the District, which will rely on the addendum, but a letter of support is not given because the scrubber is not Chevron’s only way to comply with Rule 6-5), and lighting. Staff said the Municipal Code regulates lumens, not color temperature. A commissioner proposed a condition that the upper-stack lighting (about 10 to 12 of the 93 fixtures) be 3,000 Kelvin or less if feasible; at Chevron’s request, feasibility is to be determined by the applicant, with staff to draft the language.
- Motion (about 1:18). Adopt Resolution 26-17: the addendum, the mitigation monitoring program, the CEQA findings, and approval of the conditional use permit and design review permit for PLN24-098, with the modified condition 14 and the lighting condition. A second was heard. The mover and second are not identified on the video (UNCLEAR). Approved 4–0 on the roll call: Chair Brubaker, Vice-Chair Benitez, Secretary Timmons and Commissioner Shahid yes; Commissioner Harrison absent.
H.1 — 2025 Housing Element Annual Progress Report (about 1:21–2:21; no action)
- Planning Manager Stark gave a presentation; no action was required. As heard on the video: the 2023–2031 housing element’s allocation is 3,614 units, and the City had reached about 13.14 percent of it as of the 2025 report, behind the straight-line pace; staff said about 411 building permits a year would be needed. Staff reviewed state laws that route housing projects through ministerial review (SB 35, SB 9, SB 330, SB 684 and others), and said that is why few housing projects now reach the Commission.
- Projects described as under review, approved or built included Nevin Plaza II (76 units, 100 percent affordable, SB 35), a 262-home single-family proposal still in completeness review, the Nystrom Village redevelopment (101 apartments), Metrowalk phase 2 (150 units, with a HUD award of about $42 million), and several 10-lot SB 684 projects. Staff said the Commission could see the Environmental Justice, Safety and Noise elements as soon as next month, that the Hilltop Horizon specific plan’s administrative draft is expected in March, and that comments on the sea-level-rise vulnerability assessment are open until 5 p.m. on December 18.
Commission business and adjournment (about 2:21)
- Commissioners briefly discussed how members may confer outside meetings within Brown Act limits. No other business; the Chair adjourned. Next meeting per the agenda: Thursday, 3 December 2026.
Not yet confirmed
- Who made and seconded the motion on Resolution 26-17, and the final wording of the lighting condition.
- Whether the Commission approved the minutes it set aside at the start of the meeting.
- Housing Element figures were transcribed by machine; the staff report controls. The City’s appeal period for the scrubber approval is not stated on the video.
- Answers to the property-tax and contamination-testing questions raised in the hearing; none is heard on the video.
Sources
The adopted minutes control. Check names, votes and figures against them.